PS4 News on Facebook! PS4 News on Twitter! PS4 News on YouTube! PS4 News RSS Feed!

Home PS4 News - Latest PlayStation 4 and PS3 News

February 25, 2011 // 2:21 am - Shortly following Sony's raid on his house, Dukio have now confirmed while posting a legal notice that Sony is suing Alexander Egorenkov known in the PS3 scene as Graf Chokolo for 1 million Euros and he states that he still wants to continue hacking the PlayStation 3 console with reporting he has received over $28k in donations already!

To quote: I received a legal notice from SCEE lawyers requesting me to remove the coolstuff links that graf_chokolo has distributed on as well as the links at this blog. What i found interesting in the legal notice is that the lawyers are suing graf_chokolo for 1 million euros. That is quite a number, but graf_chokolo doesn't seem to care.

He still want to hack the PS3, where he said he cannot sleep knowing that he cannot touch the hypervisor of the PS3. Man, i never see someone like graf, he is an extraordinary genius hacker that Sony wasting it by making a lawsuit against him.

Back I don't have a PC at home now guys, so i will post here only when i'm able. I will try to answer all your questions about HV and installing Linux. But expect some delays because as i said i don't have access to the Internet all the time.

You know guys, you will say i'm totally crazy now, but i never slept better than in the last 2 days I don't know how to explain this feeling but i don't care about those threats with jail and high money penalties, btw, SONY wants about 750.000 euros from me if i don't cooperate They don't know me at all I don't care about it and they might double it

The higher is the sum the higher gets my motivation They don't understand what makes me tick. Money and even my life doesn't mean to me very much without knowledge. I have a scientific mind and the knowledge is food to my brain. Without HV, Linux and FreeBSD kernel hacking my life is meaningless.

I miss my HV terribly In the last 2 days i got so “hungry” for more knowledge that i cannot control it anymore. I need knowledge and research, it has a huge meaning in my life. Jail or even death cannot hold it back anymore.

The SONY's laywer asked me why i'm doing what i'm doing, because of my hatred for SONY ? He cannot understand why i'm doing it, because he is paid for what he does. I'm not. I don't hold a grudge against SONY even now Hatred clouds your mind, keeps you from more important things. I have a better use for my mind and knowledge

So, SONY you failed again, you took my equipment but my mind is still free and you canot control it. You failed again. They are just tools, i can get new ones and will continue my HV reversing and bringing back PS3 Linux which you took from us. If you want me to stop then you should just kill me because i cannot live without programming, HV and Linux kernel hacking You know who am i and where i live, so come and get me !!!

And to prove it, i will reopen right now my HV reverse engineering page And i will post my latest findings about Update Manager and BD drive here. Most of you know already that i was able to update CORE OS from Linux. And on the last weekend i tries to hel some PS3 devs with BD drive authentication and discovered some interesting stuff about it which i will post here.

And please guys, could someone post here a link to the latest version of my cloned Linux kernel. I need it. The last week i implemnted a updater for Linux and it was finished but the police got first before i could upload it. But do not fear, i have everything in my head I can write it down again and show you how it works.

So, about BD drive authentication The most importnat HV process is 6. It contains Update Manager and Storage Manager e.g. Update manager flashes e.g. new CORE OS, BD firmware or SYSCON firmware. Storage Manager sets ATA keys, authenticates HDD and BD drives.

Storage Manager

I looked at VSH closer in the last week. And found out that VSH uses the following Storage Manager services: 05004 – to authenticate PS3 discs, 05007 – to authenticate PS3 discs.

Bothe these services can be used by GameOS through VUART 10 and Dispatcher Manager (is also in a HV process), I already implemented a driver for VUART 10 and DM on Linux and uploaded it, so guys who has my latest Linux version could use it on Linux And get access to PS3 discs and PS2 discs but i didn't have time to test it.

Both these services accept one parameter: 32 bit integer. Look at the funtion stor_mgr_packetid_0x5004 in my IDA database for HV 3.15. Everything is still the same on 3.41 and 3.55, so my HV 3.15 bible is the key to HV 3.41 and 3.55. They changed almost nothing in new HV versions And look also at function stor_mgr_packetid_0x5007. I could write down a simple Linux program which uses my DM driver to communicate with Storage Manager and show you how it works It's very easy. I will upload it maybe next week.

To authenticate PS2 discs, VSH uses parameter 052 and service 05004. To authenticate PS3 discs, VSH uses parameter 053 and service 05007. But i didn't test it on my own unfortunately.

PS3′s BD support different profiles for different media, e.g. for PS3 discs, for DVD, for PS2 discs. And storage manager can tell BD drive which profile it should use.

All the communication between Storage Manager and BD drive goes through ATAPI/SCSI interface.

To read the current profile of BD drive, the Storage Manager uses the storage device command 011, look at storage_device_RBD_do_device_command in my HV 3.15 IDA database (lv1_storage_Send_device_command) and ATAPI_GetConfiguration. But HV procs do not use HV calls, they use HV syscall, and Storage Manager sends ATAPI commands to BD drive through device file /dev/rbd0. With lv1_storage_Send_device_command(011) you could read the current BD profile.

Also very interesting ATAPI commands used by Storage Manager are Report Key/Send Key commands. Look at functions HW_report_key and HW_send_key in my HV proc 6 IDA database. HW_report_key function is e.g. used by Storage Manager to read BD drive policy. Storage Manager checks the policy of BD drive.

Storage Manager uses sv_iso_spu_module.self isolated module to authenticate BD drive. sv_iso_spu_module.self gives Storage Manager data which is sent to BD drive and back.

And look closer at function HW_disc_auth_emu in HV process 6. It’s for BD emu stor_mgr_check_drive_policy in HV prcoess 6 checks BD drive policy.

Functions storage_mgr_set_ata_key/storage_mgr_delete_ata_key sets/deletes ATA keys. These functions are used in Storage Manager service 05002. This service is used by System Manager in HV process 9 during LPAR boot.

Update Manager

The name of this service explains already the purpouse of it. The GameOS updater communicates with this service and sends encrypted packages to it. The GameOS updater stores a pkg in memory and passes the LPAR memory address of the pkg to Update Manager. Look at function update_package. This functions can update/inspect and extract packages. UM services 06001(update), 06002(inspect) and 06005 (extract) use it. Inspect just checks if a pkg is valid, Update service installs it and Extract service extracts it and you can get it back extracted from UM.

I implemnted an updater for Linux which uses all these services and it worked like a charm I could extract and inspect packages. Allocate a huge page on Linux with mmap, lock it with mlock, store there a pkg and send LPAR address to one of this service through DM. I will upload soon my PS3 Linux updater and show you how we can update firmware without GameOS even noticing it

Updater Manager object in HV process 6 has a member variable which checked during package update, and if it contains a magic valu then you can install just any package version Look at function update_manager_is_valid_access in my IDa database for HV proc 6.

Sony Sues Graf Chokolo for 1 Million Euros, He's Still PS3 Hacking!

Sony Sues Graf Chokolo for 1 Million Euros, He's Still PS3 Hacking!

PlayStation Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and join us at our new site WWW.PSXHAX.COM!

#55 - whompus60 - February 27, 2011 // 6:17 am
whompus60's Avatar
That's too technical for me to reply in anyway about the law of it all.

I will say I doubt sony holds copyright to the hypervisor, They may have purchased the right to use it as they do. If I remember right hypervisor was prodused by ibm in the 70s.

I could be wrong however, at my age comes a loss of things once known.

#54 - mik30 - February 27, 2011 // 4:58 am
mik30's Avatar
The case is judicially quite clear if you take a look at the stuff the graf is writing about and what he is spreading right now.

Here are some facts and some words about german copyright laws:

1. The graf has been writing all over the place that he has been reverse-engineering the HV and lv2 dump of the PS3.
The HV and the lv2 are both (without doubt) coyprighted material. Sony claims to be the copyright holder which seems to me
very likely.

2. According to german law abreviated "UrhG" 69c Nr. 1 "the copyright holder is the only person allowed to enduringly or temporarily replicate, fully or in part, a computerprogram by any means or form"

3. According to german law abreviated "UrhG" 69c Nr. 2 "the copyright holder is the only person allowed to translate, revise, either arrangement or other revisions of a computerprogramm or it's copys or the derived results."

4. According to german law abreviated "UrhG" 69c Nr. 3 "the copyright holder is the only person allowed to spread or rent the originals of a computerprogramm or it's replication"

5. According to german law abreviated "UrhG" 69c Nr. 4 "the copyright holder is the only person allowed to replay the computerprogram by means of wired or wireless distribution in a way that the public is able to have free access at their will"

6. Besides the riich civil opertunities which the german copyright law offers to the copyright holder (namely the right to get damages (but no punitive ones) or to applicate for a restrictive injunction) the german copyrigh law also includes criminal ariticles.

According to german law abreviated "UrhG" 106 section 1 anyone who reproduces, spreads or replays publically a protected
work or a revision or a or a transformation of it in contrast to the rules of this law or without permission of the
copyright holder can be convicted to a prison sentence of up to 3 years or with punished to pay a fine. Even the trial is punishable.

7. In german criminal laws the proscutor is allowed to order the police for a search of the home of the prosecuted person to
get clues for the crime. In harsh contrast to a US-TV series like "law & order" the german public prosecutor's office and the german crominal courts are *very* generous in giving the police search orders. In most cases the german police executes a raid even without a search order from the court or the public prosecutor's office. The defendent has to appeal such actions after they have been executed. In most cases such an appeal will be refused.

So as a result of this I would say that Sonys position in germany is very strong realting to this raid.

And by the way: The 1.000.000 amount is not a claim of money sony is asking. According to german law the plaintiff of an injunction has to tell the court the worth of the underlying matter. That is necessary because in german civil cases the plaintiff has to pay the court. This payment is calculated in relation to the worth of the conflict. The worth of 1 mio results in a courts fee of 6.684 Euro for an injunction. Sony has to pay this to get the injunction.

No a 2nd speciality of the german law comes into place: The loser of a trial has to bear all necessary costs of the trial. So after getting the injuncton Sony will sue their opponent to compensate them for this amount of money. In the end the graf will have to pay everything.

#53 - TheDevil - February 26, 2011 // 3:03 pm
TheDevil's Avatar
Can't believe a judge actually agreed to raid Graf Chokolo's house. I just can't believe they broke into someones private home just beause he leaks internal information of a product onto the Internet.

Another loss for justice.

#52 - dyceast - February 26, 2011 // 11:45 am
dyceast's Avatar
An Amazing Man... Props.. Graf.

#51 - Dragonlordfrodo - February 26, 2011 // 11:12 am
Dragonlordfrodo's Avatar
Here's a few exerpts from graf_chokolos hv bible:

"Sony giveth and sony taketh away"

"And graf_chokolo said let there be linux. And there was linux"

#50 - WheedWhack3R - February 26, 2011 // 3:51 am
WheedWhack3R's Avatar
hire him, stupid. what a bunch of pantie waste wanna be BS. If linux is returned then all is cool. Stupid legal crap like this is just putting gas on a fire. Obviously they have not figured out that talent like his cannot be contained but can be guided if they wish. $0Ny brought a knife to a tank fight. you just piss off the guy in the tank!

If he was working for them, I think $0Ny would not have had this problem in the first place. will they ever figure out how to run a darn business? replace your so so programmers that only remove features because they are too lazy to implement proper fixes and find the genius's that are willing to work to increase your profits and keep the general consumer happy. I am so sure he will magically pull a million euros out of his rear and then that will fix $0Ny's mistakes.

Learn from this and adapt to incorporate these people for future projects. cause every time you piss them off, they just try harder. I'm betting the corporate janitor is smart enough to figure that out. Its just common sense. sooner or later, one way or another they will finally figure it out.

Until then, make the most of your mess and roasts some marshmallows the fire you guys keep fueling. Corporate dumb asses. OK yea, we will remove advertised features and sue people who are consumer rights activists. That will fix every thing. WTF R U guys smoking? it should definitely be illegal. Its doing funny stuff to your brain cells.

#49 - elser1 - February 26, 2011 // 3:04 am
elser1's Avatar
hope you smash the ps3 and get all you want to out of it mate.. you are legendary.

#48 - shummyr - February 26, 2011 // 2:24 am
shummyr's Avatar
Graf is the modern day robin hood

#47 - thavarin - February 26, 2011 // 2:04 am
thavarin's Avatar
Much respect. You sir are a hero in this modern day war against Sony. Sony has really disgusted me with the things they have been doing. Keep up the good work.


#46 - xUb3rn00dlEx - February 26, 2011 // 2:02 am
xUb3rn00dlEx's Avatar
Graf you just blew my mind! My man, I will do everything I can to support you and your decision. You inspire everyone on this forum man, and if you got the balls to stand up to SONY like this, I think we all should follow in your footsteps.

Your decisions are truly what separate you from followers and turn you into a leader. Keep up the good work man, you have all our support. NOT ONE STEP BACK COMMIES!