09-22-2008 #1Takavach Guest
PlayStation 3 Video DRM: Two Strikes and You're Out
The Sony Video Store on the PlayStation Network is filled with a good selection of movies, and you can't beat the convenience of renting or even buying movies from your couch and watching them on your big screen with your PlayStation 3.
Renting movies is a joy on the system, although it would be nice to have longer than 24 hours to watch the content, but what happens when you buy a movie? As one Ars reader found out, and Sony confirmed for us, you have to be careful about what happens to your system once it's filled with video content: you have one download, one redownload, and that's it.
Noise, a forum-goer, sent out a warning after he deleted some video content to make room on his hard drive and then found he couldn't redownload the content. The PlayStation 3 support page is perfectly clear on this matter. "Purchased content can be downloaded to a single PLAYSTATION 3 or a single PSP system," it reads. "Content cannot be redownloaded once it has been downloaded to either a PLAYSTATION 3 or PSP system."
You're allowed to keep the content on one system, and you can move it to up to three PSP systems, but if you have to delete the content for any reason, it's gone? Sort of. Lincoln Davis, who handles media relations for the PlayStation Network, told Ars that you are in fact allowed one extra download, but you have to contact Sony.
"If a consumer deletes a purchased movie from their PS3, they will not be able to redownload the movie without assistance from SCEA's consumer services," he told Ars. "Consumer service can issue a redownload as a one-time courtesy, as provided by our guidelines, for the title to allow the consumer to go back and download the movie from their PSN download list."
That helps Noise, who can now get his content back-once-but it's important that PS3 owners realize just how ephemeral the bought content is. This isn't like the issue of Spore DRM where customer service seems to be willing to hand out new codes like they're candy; Sony is very clear that you can only redownload your content once after it has been purchased.
When we're discussing a system that seems to release new hardware configurations every few months and a company that actively encourages you to swap hard drives yourself, it appears users are going to run into problems if they ever decide they want to switch out their hard drive or even upgrade into a larger system; the information on the back-up utility makes it clear that video content can't be moved over to new system, although new hard drives should be safe. Sony claims that the PS3 is operating on a 10-year timeline: is one extra download, which you need to contact customer service to apply for, good enough for the next decade?
It's hard to know if this limit is Sony's doing, or if content providers have demanded this level of DRM on the movies sold through Sony's online service. Nonetheless, this could cause customers to be very cautious with their hardware or space managements; no one would dare free up the space knowing that after the one redownload their purchase is gone forever. It's also unknown what will happen with these files when you purchase a PS4-if you'd like to look that far into the future.
Sony's policy is a sobering reminder that DRM can turn your purchases into rentals at anytime, with Sony and the content providers tightly holding onto the key. More PlayStation 3 News...
09-22-2008 #2hibone Guest
I think its crazy to re-charge you to download something you already paid good money for. We dont have this service in england yet but i dont think i'd be buying films on it. There are other . . . Ahem . . . "places" to get films. I've purchased a few games off the Playstation Network. Do the same rules apply for that?!?!
09-22-2008 #3mchafer Guest
i've owned a ps3 from day 1 and never actually played it the longer i own it the more frustrated i feel about buying it. i played the movie that i got free with it but i cant say i was to impressed. its a big black brick that sony needs to loosen the reigns on a bit i think they are getting a littlle to bullish in this drm stuff to get a huge customer base who knows that 10 year period may be cut short by sony suicide.
09-22-2008 #4supagene Guest
You can load a game on up to 5 consoles I believe.
09-22-2008 #5netpredakonn Guest
This is just plain ridiculous... its like not owning something you bought, unless of course they state they incur in downloading costs each time you get the movie. Anyway, more crap from Sony.
09-22-2008 #6jhfit Guest
I think the whole Sony Video rental is bull. I would think that Sony would try to pull in the people that get movies in "other places". I get almost ALL my movies from "other places", but I would definitely pay for them through PSN if they offered a better rental price. Say a subscription instead. Ive said this before, if they could make it to where you pay a set monthly fee to subscribe, giving renters a set number of downloads and redownloads. They can keep the "purchase's" and "onetime rentals" the same but add a subscription. Anyway just my opinion...
09-22-2008 #7RePtOr Guest
09-23-2008 #8dwashere Guest
Owning something and you need to re-own it back.. it's just-WTF?
10-03-2008 #9supagene Guest
I don't know about you guys, but I can't even stand watching Cable or Satellite on my 46 inch HDTV. The compression artifacts such as mosquito noise just bothers the hell out of me. If I do watch some download it's on my computer at a much smaller size so at least it doesn't look that bad. If I want to watch something good on TV I usually just rent it in bluray from netflix. Nothing can compare to bluray right now.