PS4 News on Facebook! PS4 News on Twitter! PS4 News on YouTube! PS4 News RSS Feed!

Home PS4 News - Latest PlayStation 4 and PS3 News

September 14, 2008 // 3:44 pm - Planning to buy a Blu-ray player? Hold on. It's already battling public indifference, technical problems, laughable features and downloadable movies. Is it any wonder Blu-ray is doomed to fail? Here are five reasons why it's heading for the grave...

1. HD movie downloads

OK so the picture quality's not quite there yet, but Bill Gates, Steve Jobs and others have already seen the future of movie viewing at home - and it doesn't come on shiny 12cm discs.

Instead services like iTunes, Xbox Live and Vudu already offer HD movies over the internet, enabling you to see the movies you want without having to hack down to the video store in the pouring rain.

With fibre-to-home broadband slowly being rolled out in the UK, who knows what the next few years will bring.

2. BD-Live

Have you seen the demos? BD-Live is a joke. It's a second-rate attempt to offer interactive features that HD DVD did first and much, much better.

It won't work on old Blu-ray players (they don't have the persistent storage) and may not work on new ones: it's not mandatory for Blu-ray player makers to include it in the hardware they sell.

Result? Large doses of confusion and frustration for anyone (un)lucky enough to buy a Blu-ray disc with BD-Live features on it.

3. Samsung thinks Blu-ray is finished

You know, the world's number one consumer electronics maker, Blu-ray stalwart.

Andy Griffiths, director of consumer electronics at Samsung UK, told Pocket Lint that Blu-ray would be dead in five years, and that it certainly wouldn't last 10.

He believes the format will be replaced by either a new kind of physical media - most likely flash memory cards if Toshiba's IFA 2008 keynote is anything to go by - or downloads. Go figure.

4. Sony thinks Blu-ray is finished

Blu-ray is not only finished in terms of spec, but it's also finished as a format. Optical disc technology has gone as far as it can go.

Or so says Take Miyama, Sony product manager for home video marketing in Europe believes. He told Electric Pig that "in the future, if [our emphasis] we have a physical media format, it will change physically. It won't look like an optical disc."

Talk of a 500GB Blu-ray prototype will only prolong the agony.

Sony has already hinted at its future direction with the launch of Bravia TVs in the US that can directly receive movies streamed over the internet. Blu-ray player not required.

5. DVD is good enough

Despite the fact that Blu-ray movies are expected to hit to 12 million sales in Europe this year, they still account for just two per cent of video sales in countries like the UK.

Even by 2012 DVD will still have the edge - and that's according to the Blu-ray Disc Association's own over-enthusiastic predictions [PDF link].

The plain fact is few of us are ever likely to swap extensive DVD collection for their Blu-ray equivalents, especially when prices for Blu-ray movies and players are still so high.

Given that many cheap DVD players now have some kind of upscaling capability, DVD will prove 'good enough' in terms of picture quality for many years to come.

Here's why Blu-ray will be Dead by 2012

PlayStation Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and join us at our new site WWW.PSXHAX.COM!

#15 - Kengro - September 29, 2008 // 9:55 am
Kengro's Avatar
In a few years there will be something better than blu-ray out, the development is going too fast for it to stay long at the moment. DRM will sooner or later be gone, and blu-ray will go with it.

#14 - JenniferAtSony - September 25, 2008 // 10:10 pm
JenniferAtSony's Avatar
Check out the Sony Electronics Blog. A recent post talks about why Sony thinks Blu-ray is here to stay, despite contrary reports.


Jennifer Peterson
Sony Electronics Blog Moderator
Sony Electronics

#13 - CyanCaze - September 25, 2008 // 3:09 pm
CyanCaze's Avatar
I would have to disagree with this. I don't believe optical disks will die unless something new and improved comes out.
I say this because there is a good majority of the people in this world that are like me.

What is like me? Well I prefer to go to the store and buy a psychical copy of what I own rather then order it over the internet. Why is this? Well there are some major flaws with ordering over the internet.

1 Psychical Objects: If you order a psychical Object from a retailer such as, There is a small chance (About 10% maybe less) That the object will be broken when you receive it. This has happened to me multiple times. And I don't order stuff over the internet very often anymore because of that fact.

2 Downloads: Downloads have a few flaws in them selves. Although I can order it for cheaper most of the time. The main Issue is space.

Now this wouldn't be a problem. If we had say.. 20 Terabyte hdd's. However this is a long ways away before video game consoles get that advanced.

My next problem with downloads is the time. Downloads are very time consuming and most of the time I have to leave my PS3 on over night to download a full game. So going to the store is a no brainier to me.

So in my opinion I can Either.

A: Grab my key's drive to the store. pay about 10 more USD then I would over the internet. Drive back. Pop it into my disk drive. and go from there.

B: Order something over the internet for the same price I would get it at the store. Wait for it. It arrives to me. Has a 10% chance of being broken. I send it back wait another 6 weeks until I finally call them. They say "We forgot to ship it" And then I wait another 2 weeks until it finally arrives, and then stick it into my disk drive. Or...

C: Order it over the internet Slightly Cheaper and wait for 10 hours when it downloads.

I my self would go for A but if you don't that's your opinion and I respect it.

#12 - PeacefulDiscord - September 25, 2008 // 12:56 pm
PeacefulDiscord's Avatar
I still believe optical media will reign in some form, even after downloadable content. See, if for example the PS4 or whatever had no optical drive of any form and downloading content such as games was the only choice for consumers, then the risks of that download getting lost, corrupted, deleted, etc. would be the main reason for having a backup. But unlike a simple MP3 download where you can just copy the file onto a MemStick and transport it anywhere, these downloadable content will be software-protected to protect them from piracy...

Like how on the PS3 you can't copy a game bought on PSN onto your external HDD. You have to be careful not to accidentally wipe your entire HDD or delete the file. This is where back-ups would come in handy. Even though you can ask for another copy of the game by emailing Sony, you can't keep asking them for a new copy every time something happens.
Basically, Blu-Ray and all forms of optical media will still stay alive until a smaller form, in terms of physical size, of optical media comes out.

Blu-Ray will take a while to catch on. Companies are not helping the format by releasing 'DVD players with upscaling technology' that is supposed to give you the same experience as any other HD movie or not researching in ways that they can manufacture Blu-Ray at a cheaper cost, so as to appeal to the price factor many of us have.

#11 - MagikRevolver - September 24, 2008 // 1:59 am
MagikRevolver's Avatar
No, it won't be dead within 5 years. We will all have to buy the Manned Mission to Mars Blu-ray disc to taste the full experience when NASA lands on MARS.

Also, If you believe in the Mayan calendar, we will all be dead in 2012, so it won't matter.

In all honesty though, the death of Blu-Ray does indeed mean the death of optical media. New technologies are coming out every week that make basic electronics better; the resistor, transistor, and inductor are not the three kings any more. Technology like memristors will make boot instantaneous on computers within a very short time frame.

I'm sure everyone has heard of the atom thick carbon transistor. Just these two new (kind of new, at least outside of theory) elements could lead to technology of paper thin computers, once again not far from now. That being said, Blu-Ray won't be dead by 2012. Electronics as we know it will be dead by 2012.

#10 - picc0lo - September 22, 2008 // 6:39 pm
picc0lo's Avatar
I don't believe Blue-Ray will be dead anytime soon. In fact the Blue-Ray industry is just at it's beginning. We've seen it happen with the DVD and look how popular it is. The only way I see Blue-Ray dying off is they invent a totally new type of medium, which I haven't heard off yet.

#9 - Warrorar - September 22, 2008 // 12:43 pm
Warrorar's Avatar
i like it to read those threads Blue Ray is a child of the DVD. and like the 20years before. every child of the CD is the future.

Microsoft lost millions of dollars 10years ago. when the whole world started to use CD's, and microsoft said "no zip is the future".

then blue ray gets released some years later and microsoft trys his own way with HD DVD. and now? febuary the news was released that hd dvd is cancled. the project is dead. microsoft lost again a fight.

and this will happens all the time again. nobody can win against the cd and his childs (dvd/blueray). and the future is also leaded by this line of technology.

for so long its clear that internet download movies gets more popular. but where to put this datas? blueray will be the save medium of the future. a double layer dvd with 8gb is allready to small to hold some films. because they have so much informations and datas that only a blue ray can hold the informations.

blue ray will never day. and i think in 10 years they will release a new children with will also win the fight against what ever microsoft and the rest will release.

#8 - Treacles - September 22, 2008 // 12:32 pm
Treacles's Avatar
Didnt HD and DVD take ages to become well known and pretty cheap? Just because something starts with no sales and pretty expensive, doesnt mean in the future it wont be the best way to watch movies... When we have things like 2000 P/I (Obviously just rough guess) you think DVD or HD would be able to handle that without 2 discs?

#7 - ricdee - September 16, 2008 // 7:04 pm
ricdee's Avatar
I've been watching high definition movies ever since ps3 launch and i cant go back now. whenever i watch dvds now they look awful and thats even when their upscaled. Blu-ray WILL catch on in a big way someday, prices will drop and blu-ray discs will be the norm.

Saying downloads is the way to go is a bit stupid in that you have to have the internet and a HD ready device and given that the ps3 is probably the most affordable Blu-ray player at the moment most people will buy that and demand for blu-ray movies will go up and they wont need a download service.

#6 - jon5555 - September 16, 2008 // 11:58 am
jon5555's Avatar
Given that many cheap DVD players now have some kind of upscaling capability, DVD will prove 'good enough' in terms of picture quality for many years to come.

Is he serious? I don't think he's ever watched a Blu Ray movie on a Full HD setup. Upscaling quality is poor on cheap DVD players. Not to mention supposed HD downloads are a joke, most looking more like a VHS copy.

If its a action packed blockbuster I simply must watch it on blu ray. DVD picture quality sadly just doesn't cut it for me anymore.